12 min read
Top Agencies

Top 17 Paid Media Agencies in the U.S. (2024)

Herd 1 profile
Jack Shepherd
Co-Founder & Marketing Director
Updated on 23 Apr 2024

We understand that finding a trusted and reliable agency can require a lot of legwork. That's precisely why we've put together this comprehensive article, bringing you a curated list of the finest agencies all in one place.

No more sifting through the overwhelming 679,000,000 search results that Google dishes out. We've got you covered, whether you're in eCommerce, B2C, B2B, SaaS, or running a small business.

Excited to discover the top 17 Paid Media agencies making waves in the U.S.?

Let's dive right in.

What Makes a Top Paid Media Agency?

The fact is that not all performance marketing agencies in the U.S. are created equal. This selection isn't based solely on our criteria but also takes into account the key factors that distinguish a top-notch performance marketing agency.

  • Proven Track Record & Results: To gauge the credibility of an agency, it's crucial to examine its track record and tangible results. Explore their case studies and contact their clients for references to confirm their ability to deliver on their promises.

  • Specialization: Different businesses have unique needs. Whether you operate a B2B company, an eCommerce venture, or a small business, ensure that the agency has relevant experience in your industry and caters to your business size. For instance, if you run an eCommerce business, you'd want an agency like The Social Shepherd, which specializes in helping brands that sell products online. However, this might not be the ideal fit for B2B enterprises.

  • Channel Expertise: Your paid media strategy may require expertise in specific channels, such as Paid Social. Go beyond surface-level claims and delve into the agency's case studies to confirm their proficiency across various channels. You need an agency that can tap into the opportunities offered by different facets of Paid Media.

  • Effective Communication: Effective communication is the bedrock of a successful partnership. Assess how the agency communicates during the proposal and introductory stages. Is their communication efficient and friendly? It's essential that their communication style aligns with your preferences and the way you like to work.

Now that you're equipped with the criteria to identify a top-tier paid media agency, let's get into the top paid media agencies you can find in the U.S.!

Top Paid Media Agencies

1. The Social Shepherd

The Social Shepherd Top Paid Media Agencies

When it comes to finding a top-tier paid media agency in the U.S., look no further than The Social Shepherd. We pride ourselves on being a performance-driven marketing agency with a proven track record of rapidly scaling eCommerce businesses to new heights.

What Our Paid Media Offering Includes:

  • Paid Social & Paid Search: Our expertise spans across both paid social media and search engine advertising, ensuring your brand gets the visibility it deserves in the digital landscape.

  • Channel & Media Strategy: We craft customized strategies that align with your business goals and resonate with your target audience.

  • Optimization & A/B Testing: Constant refinement is key to success. We continually optimize campaigns and conduct A/B testing to ensure your ad spend delivers maximum results.

  • Feed Management & Optimization: We take care of the nitty-gritty details, including feed management and optimization, so you can focus on growing your business.

  • Creative Strategy: Our creative team is second to none, generating innovative and high-converting ad creatives that capture attention and drive engagement.

  • Conversion & Brand Awareness: Whether you aim to boost conversions or raise brand awareness, we have the strategies to make it happen.

What Sets Us Apart From the Rest:

At The Social Shepherd, our dedicated specialists, who excel in paid social and paid search, ensure tailored solutions. We've effectively managed monthly spending exceeding $500,000 and generated over $100 million in client revenue.

Our unique, comprehensive reports provide unmatched insights. We scrutinize multiple attribution models for true performance understanding. With a creative team skilled in graphics, user-generated content, and hero videos, we drive engagement and conversions.

We've achieved Google Premier Partner status - the highest tier in the Google Partners program for our ability to drive success for our clients.

While we're proud of our achievements, we let our results speak for themselves, ensuring your confidence in our expertise and commitment to your success.

  • Over 146,000 Customers Acquired: Leveraging Facebook Ads, we successfully brought in a customer base exceeding 146,000 for Beebombs while boosting their Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) by an impressive 87%.

  • Robust 30% ROAS Boost: Nu-In experienced a remarkable 30% increase in ROAS as we strategically scaled their budgets.

  • 8.2x ROAS Achievement: Love Leggings saw an extraordinary 8.2x Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) while more than doubling their advertising budget.

  • Exceptional 15x ROAS: We achieved an exceptional 15x Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) for a high-end homeware brand.

  • Explosive Subscriber Growth: We catapulted a food subscription box service from 2,000 to over 25,000 monthly subscribers.

  • Revenue Surge of 3.74x: We spearheaded a clothing brand's growth, resulting in a substantial 3.74x increase in revenue.

Work with our award-winning team of 60+ experts, with offices spanning New York, Miami, and the UK. Let's make your success story together—reach out today!

2. Marcel Digital

Marcel Digital, a leader in paid media strategy, utilizes cutting-edge technology, optimization tactics, and rigorous testing to maximize ROI. Their integrated approach spans paid search, programmatic, display, and paid social, ensuring targeted ad delivery, landing page optimization, and creative development.

Specialists at Marcel Digital reduce costs and boost revenue through research, precise targeting, continuous testing, competitor analysis, and ongoing optimizations. As a Google Premier Partner, they hold top certifications in various platforms, delivering holistic strategies and visible results.

Trusted clients include LightMark, Medius, and Printable Promotions, with headquarters in Chicago, IL.

Marcel Digital Top Paid Media Agencies

3. Uncommon Logic

Uncommon Logic, with clients like IBM, Blue Apron, and Milliken, specializes in meticulous display, remarketing, and platform-driven advertising. Their daily account monitoring and hands-on paid media management ensure efficient spending and risk control while achieving extensive reach.

Their services encompass:

  • Display advertising

  • Remarketing

  • Programmatic advertising

  • Social media platform ads

  • Video ads

Uncommon Logic is headquartered in Austin, TX, providing top-tier expertise in the field.

Uncommon Logic Top Paid Media Agencies

4. Powered by Search

Powered by Search, with a client roster featuring renowned SaaS giants like VMWare, Fortra, and Basecamp, is a powerhouse in B2B SaaS marketing. With a track record spanning over 70 B2B SaaS companies, ranging from $1M to $100M ARR, they've perfected the art of testing and scaling paid media campaigns.

Impressive B2B Results:

  • Increased MRR by 15%: Their strategies have consistently boosted Monthly Recurring Revenue for clients.

  • 34% MoM Cost Reduction: They slashed the cost per trial activation from PPC campaigns by 34% month-over-month.

  • 22% Growth in Google Ads Sign-ups: Despite spending reductions of 7%, Google Ads sign-ups saw a remarkable 22% increase.

Powered by Search boasts a global team, distributed across 8+ countries in North America, Europe, and Asia Pacific. Specializing in both organic and paid traffic acquisition, they excel in crafting compelling copy and offers, as well as creating and promoting content that resonates with your ideal prospects and customers. Their headquarters are located in Toronto.

Powered by Search Top Paid Media Agencies

5. Kanbar Digital

Kanbar Digital, a reputable digital marketing agency headquartered in San Diego, specializes in crafting targeted digital ad strategies. By harnessing your company's data and their cutting-edge technology, they excel at tailoring ad campaigns to engage your specific audience.

Their approach is rooted in extensive research and industry best practices. Through meticulous analysis of trends, consumer behaviors, and proprietary data, Kanbar Digital ensures that your digital ads effectively reach the intended audience.

They meticulously consider elements such as frequency caps, content types, tone, needs, wants, and assistance to deliver a strategic ad experience. This guarantees that your brand's products and services gain visibility among interested parties and those in need of your solutions. Noteworthy clients in their portfolio include Adobe, Doordash, and Experian.

Kanbar Digital Top Paid Media Agencies

6. Goodway Group

Goodway Group is the trusted partner for major national brands spanning industries like automotive, healthcare, and QSR (quick-service restaurants). Notable clients include Dr. Pepper, Subaru, and Bagel Brands. With roots dating back to 1929 as a printing company, Goodway Group has continually adapted to lead the marketing industry.

Today, they offer comprehensive digital media strategy and execution, complemented by a data-driven approach and customized consulting services. Their forward-thinking approach includes pioneering virtual work in 2008, with headquarters in New York, ensuring they are prepared to meet your business needs regardless of what the future holds.

Goodway Group Top Paid Media Agencies

7. Northern

Northern boasts premier-level agency partnerships with major ad platforms like TikTok, Pinterest, Snapchat, and is recognized as both a Meta Business Partner and Google Partner. As Canada's top eCommerce agency, they provide comprehensive solutions to businesses across London, Toronto, and the U.S. Impressive clients include Milwaukee, Canadian Tire, and Chatters.

Their expert team specializes in crafting and executing data-informed media strategies, aligning past performance with desired outcomes to optimize channel and media selection. Their services encompass account audits, KPI benchmarking, goal setting, budget planning, and the development of an ideal media mix.

Northern Top Paid Media Agencies

8. JPL

JPL excels in Paid Media Planning, Buying & Analytics, prioritizing results over clicks. With dedicated in-house teams, they focus on extracting meaningful insights and delivering outcomes. Proactive media management and optimization ensure your message reaches the right audience at the right moment.

Clients include renowned names like Hershey, Trex, and AAA. Offices are strategically located in Harrisburg, PA, New York City, and Glenside, PA.

Key Capabilities:

  • Media Strategy, Planning & Forecasting

  • Audience Hyper-Targeting

  • Anti-Fraud Tech Stack

  • Campaign Development and Execution

  • Data, Analytics & Optimization

JPL Top Paid Media Agencies

9. Augurian

Augurian is a staunch advocate for the power of paid digital advertising in swiftly elevating brand recognition and scaling outbound initiatives. They recognize it as one of the most measurable digital marketing strategies, particularly regarding ROI.

Augurian's core mission revolves around eliminating wasteful advertising expenditure. Their expertise lies in orchestrating persuasive digital dialogues with prospects, ensuring that the right message reaches them at the precise moments in their customer journey.

Augurian specializes in crafting strategic paid media marketing campaigns tailored to your needs, encompassing:

  • Display Advertising

  • Paid Search (Bing, Google Ads, Yahoo, etc.)

  • Paid Social (Facebook, LinkedIn, X (Twitter), etc.)

  • Programmatic Advertising

With their headquarters in Minneapolis, MN, Augurian has proudly served clients like Digi International, Unity College, and Vanco, positioning themselves as trusted guides to success in paid search and paid social.

Augurian Top Paid Media Agencies

10. Disruptive

Disruptive is a prominent digital marketing agency with an impressive client roster including Davinci, Guitar Center, and Horse&Rider. With over 150 full-time employees, they manage an annual spend exceeding $450 million.

Their operations encompass optimizing thousands of web pages, delivering tens of thousands of emails, texts, and chats, and analyzing hundreds of thousands of data points annually.

Their expertise in paid media extends across various components, including paid search, Shopping & Feed Management, paid social, performance display, Amazon advertising, and Remarketing. Disruptive is headquartered in Pleasant Grove, UT, and they are known for their impactful digital strategies.

Disruptive Top Paid Media Agencies

11. Socium

Socium, headquartered in New York City, is a performance-driven digital marketing agency with an impressive client portfolio featuring World Market, Modern Age, and Tushy. They specialize in ensuring that your brand seamlessly integrates into customers' lives in the digital space.

In 2022 alone, they planned, launched, and expertly managed over $150 million in ad spend across 15+ platforms, solidifying their reputation as the ideal partner for finding and acquiring the right customers in a competitive digital landscape.

Socium Top Paid Media Agencies

12. Megethos

Megethos, headquartered in Scottsdale, AZ, is an award-winning paid media management agency, serving esteemed clients like TripSpark, BATCADDY, and AirCARE1. They excel in creating, managing, and optimizing multi-channel PPC campaigns that drive results.

Megethos is dedicated to helping businesses of all sizes and types elevate their campaigns. Whether it's lead generation or e-commerce, they specialize in PPC campaigns tailored to meet your business objectives.

Their integrated, cross-channel approach, data-driven focus, and scalable campaigns ensure they deliver results, both domestically and internationally. As a Google and Microsoft Advertising Partner, they offer reasonable management fees for their expert services.

Megethos Top Paid Media Agencies

13. SmartBug Media

SmartBug Media, located in Newport Beach, CA, proudly serves clients like Wyvern, Ltd., HD Stor, and Saxton Woods. They understand the importance of making your content easily discoverable to your buyer personas.

SmartBug Media takes on the heavy lifting, identifying the best keywords and phrases to create and execute effective paid search and social campaigns. Whether your buyer personas search on Google or trust their business and social networks, SmartBug ensures you're the answer to their problems. Their paid search services will, boost your rankings for solution-based keywords, and paid social will ensure your presence in the social feeds and timelines of your personas.

SmartBug Media Top Paid Media Agencies

14. Digilant

Based in Boston, MA, Digilant is a part of ispDigital, boasting a team of 100+ data-driven media experts and advertising technologists. Their client services extend beyond Boston to New York, Chicago, Denver, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Kansas City, Washington D.C., Dallas, and Atlanta.

Their paid search team collaborates with leading platforms like Google, Microsoft, Amazon, and Yahoo!, ensuring trustworthy management of your investments.

They recognize the unique nuances of each social platform and maintain a dedicated team of campaign management and strategy experts for social media. These hands-on-keyboard specialists offer actionable insights on topical social subjects.

Digilant's Facebook agency partnership grants them access to advanced support services, exclusive training, and industry-leading campaign management approaches. Their entire social team is Blueprint-trained, solidifying their expertise in the field.

Digilant Top Paid Media Agencies

15. Rayneta

Rayneta, headquartered in Los Angeles, is a growth-focused partner for clients like Disney, Fujitsu, and Lyft. They offer data-driven paid media solutions designed to help you acquire customers and boost revenue.

Their small, yet expert team delivers results through a boutique agency approach that seamlessly integrates with your team. Rayneta customizes strategies for each brand, providing expert media planning and buying across various channels:

  • Paid Social

  • Paid Search

  • Programmatic

  • Out-of-Home (OOH)

  • Audio Advertising

  • Connected TV

Rayneta Top Paid Media Agencies

16. Whiteshark Media

Whiteshark Media, headquartered in Miami, FL, is your premier Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram ad agency. Their team of digital marketing experts is committed to driving success for businesses across diverse industries.

They tackle online market challenges with a wealth of experience, a deep understanding of the field, and a dedication to continuous learning, all aimed at helping you achieve your business goals effectively.

Whiteshark Media Top Paid Media Agencies

17. Mynt

Mynt, headquartered in Saint Charles, IL, specializes in paid social media campaigns tailored for growth and sales. They elevate social conversations, enhance brand awareness, and drive product and service sales through robust paid social media strategies. Noteworthy clients include Orly, Andro400, and LaserAway.

Mynt Agency comprises an action-oriented team of marketing and advertising experts, consistently exceeding goals. With a track record of guiding numerous companies to success, they bring expertise, energy, and resources to help you conquer your competitive landscape.

Their curated arsenal of tools and tactics ensures explosive growth for your company, delivering increased reach, customers, and brand lift through a commitment to accountability, transparency, and partnership.

Mynt Top Paid Media Agencies

Why Hire One of the Best Paid Media Agencies?

Your brand deserves nothing less than the best.

Choosing an underperforming Paid Media agency can lead to wasted budget on ineffective campaigns, outweighing any cost difference between a good and subpar agency.

Moreover, a top-tier agency will help you achieve your goals faster than an inexperienced one. This is precisely where The Social Shepherd excels.

We deliver substantial growth and ROI in Paid Search & Paid Social, thanks to our team of seasoned media buyers who are adept at tailoring the right strategy for your brand.

Ready to chat with our Paid Media experts? Click the button below to get in touch.

Herd 1 profile
Written by
Jack Shepherd
Hi! I'm Jack, Co-Founder of Social Shepherd. I didn't choose the name of the agency, but now you can see where it's from...
Get in touch with our team
Want to learn more about our Paid Media services? Click the button below.

Don’t be sheepish
let’s talk

DSC01726 2